He’s not perfect, but he sure is cheap

If news reports are to be believed, Arsenal have swooped in and made a £750k offer for Manchester United whipping post Mikael Silvestre.  I don’t want to put too fine a point on this but my initial reaction is: don’t Arsenal have enough error prone defenders?  And, wouldn’t it be better to let our youngsters make mistakes than let a washed up old man (he’s 31) come in to the team and let teams like Watford score on us?  I mean, if Djourou or Song make a mistake, there’s an opportunity for them to learn from it.  But if Silvestre makes a mistake, well, he’s already had a career full of them I don’t see him getting better.

I guess you get what you pay for and £750k is just about the right price.  Because, on the one hand, Silvestre has won 4 League medals, an FA Cup, the League Cup, Jose Mourinho’s favorite trophy (the Community Shield), and most notably a Champions League medal.  And on the other hand, he’s also provided some comically bad defending in all of those tournaments; defending so bad that United often won in spite of the player.

Another thing that’s odd about the player is that whenever he makes a huge mistake in a game, it seems like he then redeems himself by either scoring a goal or providing an assist — in that same game.  That link isn’t the only example, just google him and you’ll see what I’m talking about.  It’s rather uncanny.

I guess, regardless of all this stuff, he’s damn near the perfect Arsenal signing: he’s big, pacy, versatile, French, cheap, and technically good.  He’d be the absolute perfect Arsenal signing if he was 16 and completely unknown.  Plus, theoretically, bringing in Silvestre will challenge Senderos and Djourou for the backup center half spot and provide needed cover for Gael Clichy at Left Back.  These are all good things and so, maybe £750k makes him a steal.

Oh yeah, one more thing…  signing Silvestre would prove me wrong on just about every front.  Wenger mentioned buying a Premiership player; I said he wouldn’t do it.  Wenger said he wanted a defender; I said he wouldn’t do it.  Wenger said he needed one more body; I said he wouldn’t do it.  It would be just like Wenger to prove loud mouthed bloggers like me wrong.  Go on, Arsene, sign the guy, it’s a bargain.


Arsene Wenger made an impassioned plea for everyone to give Theo Walcott some room to breathe, much less grow. Sure Arsene, I don’t think I really criticize him, in fact I like the kid quite a bit.  If anything, I think the team doesn’t respect him enough: there have been whole matches where his teammates just don’t look for him.  But maybe that’s something he can work on, imposing himself on his teammates a bit more.  I don’t know, according to the boss, Theo’s a footballing genius, maybe he’ll figure all that out.

And that’s it for today.  If Arsenal sign someone I’ll make a second blog.  If not, see you tomorrow!


3 Responses to “He’s not perfect, but he sure is cheap”

  1. 1 Faz
    August 20, 2008 at 6:34 am

    First of all wenger would never go for him and I do not think man united would ever sell their player to help arsenal in anyway to win the title,(which they still are going to win with or without silvestre) maybe they need alonso for the little edge in their game as he is somone who can make something out of nothing, trust me.

  2. 2 ad
    August 20, 2008 at 12:27 pm

    lol faz hes signed, shows how much you no. you can never predict what wenger will do.
    i was going to flame wenger but for 750,000 its a good buy

Comments are currently closed.

RSS My Google Reader

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Flickr Photos


Arsenal Community

Arsenal News

Arsenal News


%d bloggers like this: